Judge rejects Legislature's request to dismiss challenge to Senate redistricting plan

Peter Schorsch | Saint Petersblog | 01/17/2013

A Leon County judge has rejected a request from the Legislature to dismiss a challenge to a Senate redistricting plan approved last year, the first ruling in what could be a precedent-setting case under the new Fair Districts standards.

A spokeswoman for Senate President Don Gaetz suggested an appeal was inevitable.

The dispute comes in a case filed by a group of citizens and a coalition of voting-rights groups against the new Senate district boundaries, which opponents say violate the redistricting constitutional amendments approved by voters in a 2010 referendum. The Fair Districts Amendments were adopted in an effort to curb politically gerrymandered districts.

At issue in the case is a statement the constitution makes in a different section about the Supreme Court’s automatic review of legislative redistricting maps: “A judgment of the supreme court of the state determining the apportionment to be valid shall be binding upon all the citizens of the state.”

Because the Supreme Court approved a second draft of the Senate map — it voided the first draft — in April, attorneys for the House and Senate argued that there was no room for new challenges.

Those fighting the Senate map said that would make it nearly impossible to enforce the new standards, because the Supreme Court doesn’t handle “as-applied” cases — which consider facts as well as the law — like circuit courts do. Instead, the high court only reviews “facial” challenges dealing with anything in the map that was obviously unconstitutional.

A circuit judge, for example, could hear testimony or consider exhibits dealing with why lawmakers drew the maps a certain way.

“To the extent that the plaintiffs seek only a rehash of facial arguments made before the Florida Supreme Court, they will be disappointed,” Leon County Circuit Judge Terry Lewis wrote Thursday. “But to the extent their claims are as-applied challenges to the plans, they are entitled to develop and to present relevant evidence to support their claims. The defendants likewise are entitled to prepare and present contrary evidence in defense.”

Adam Schachter, a lawyer for opponents of the map, applauded the decision in a statement.

“Judge Lewis’ order means that Floridians will have their day in court,” Schachter said. “This ruling gives our citizens the right to scrutinize the conduct and motives of those who drew the map.”

An appeal is nearly certain.

“We always expected that this matter would be decided by the Florida Supreme Court,” Gaetz spokeswoman Katie Betta said in an email. “A bipartisan majority of the Senate, the Florida Supreme Court and the U.S. Department of Justice approved these maps, the matter has been already been litigated at great length and the people of Florida are ready to move on.”

Via Brandon Larrabee of the News Service of Florida.

copyright © 2013 Saint Petersblog. All Rights Reserved


Legal battle over state Senate districts coming to an end

01/20/2016
TALLAHASSEE - A contentious battle over Florida state senate districts is coming to an end. read more »

Senate won't appeal redistricting ruling

01/20/2016
Clearing the way for elections later this year with a map that could boost Democrats' numbers in the Senate, Republican leaders decided Wednesday not to appeal a Leon County judge's ruling setting districts for the chamber's 40 seats. read more »

Florida Senate won't appeal ruling on new districts

01/20/2016
TALLAHASSEE — Senate leaders said Wednesday that they will not appeal last month's court ruling that sided with a voters' coalition in setting new district boundaries. read more »

Florida Legislature won't appeal redistricting ruling

01/20/2016
TALLAHASSEE — The Florida Legislature is giving up the fight and will not contest a court ruling that redraws all of the state's 40 state senate districts for the 2016 election cycle. read more »

Editorial: Republicans should accept redistricting defeat and drop talk of appeals

01/10/2016
For a brief moment last week it appeared the Florida Legislature had come to its senses and was willing to accept a judge's ruling on the boundaries for new state Senate districts. read more »

Renumbering state Senate districts triggers political scramble

01/10/2016
TALLAHASSEE — It may sound like a simple process, but the Florida Senate's random renumbering of all its districts statewide Tuesday touched off a series of complicated twists that one key lawmaker said only adds more chaos to a continuing redistricting saga. read more »